1-2-3-4, We Want More of Your Stinkin War

Ross Douthat looks at some polling of GOP primary voters and finds some troubling trends:

When asked to name the issue they care most about, 31 percent of Republican voters picked the War in Iraq, another 17 percent picked terrorism, and another 8 percent picked "foreign policy." More potential GOP primary voters picked Iraq, in particular, than picked the economy, health care, education, abortion, and immigration combined. So while in a peacetime primary season, savvy candidates would be paying attention to, say, the fact that the Republican base is more amenable to universal health-care and anti-poverty spending than it used to be, in this primary season there's little to be gained from taking any risks on domestic policy, because the winner is going to be the guy who voters want in charge of the war in Iraq, full stop. Similarly, whereas in a peacetime primary season, Rudy Giuliani might have fumbled onward with his "I hate abortion/I like Sam Alito/I'm pro-choice/a judge could decide either way" eight-step because the alternative was certain defeat, in this primary season his "Iraq should trump abortion" line actually might have a chance of playing in Peoria.

The difficulty, of course, is that a primary battle fought entirely over who’s going to kick the most ass in Iraq, with rote invocations of Reagan substituting for policy debate on virtually every other issue, is likely to produce a nominee wildly out-of-step with the concerns of the larger electorate. (It’s a very bad sign for the GOP when Frank Rich’s analysis of the party’s woes is largely correct.) In this context, the frontloaded primary season may be the only thing that can save the Republicans from defeat in ‘08, since it will give the eventual nominee time to refit his campaign for November – time that it looks like he’ll desperately need.

Chris Hayes is the host of All In with Chris Hayes on MSNBC.


Join Chris’s email list.